Romaine S

Reviews

Superhost

34 total reviews

85% rated 5★

34 reviews

4.82

2023–2026

Cleanliness 4.9

Accuracy 4.8

Communication 4.8

Location 4.6

Check-in 4.6

Value 4.5

34 reviews

4BR Villa in Isla Mujeres

Edgar

Excellent, 4 months ago

I really liked the house; it is very comfortable. The area where it is located is very busy, but it was pleasant to be there.

This place was such a gem. Felt very safe. The pool was beautiful and amazing. No photo tricks making the place look bigger than it was. It’s a slight jaunt from the busy north party size of the island so rent a golf cart. But we absolutely loved the neighborhood. There were a few sweet local-style restaurants near by and also some fancier, delicious restaurants in a very short cart ride or slightly longer walk (I’m talking a ten min walk, if that). The beds were cozy and the AC was kickin! Every part of this place was well thought out. Salt, pepper, cooking oil and many spices were provided. Bring coffee and milk, but there is every part of a full functioning kitchen available. Also…. Coolest thing I’ve seen…. Filtered water from the blue five gallon jugs, pumped into the fridge for ice and cold water. Above and beyond grateful for this stay with our friends. (Group of 8 total, 4 adults and 4 pre-teens. Didn’t feel crowded at all).

Casa Macabi was the perfect getaway for our family. Centrally located on the island, it was walking distance to a ton of great restaurants (the ones we loved were Limón, taqueria Daniela, Bastos and Daisy & Raul’s). Rooftop is great spot to watch the sunset and we walked down the street to the beach to watch the sunrise. The home itself is very spacious. The bedrooms are large and the open concept - indoor/outdoor living space with the pool was where we spent most of our time. The kitchen is fully stocked with all the equipment you need to make a proper meal. The Super Aki grocery store is two blocks right down the street and made it easy to get all of our essentials. Communication was straightforward and made check in and check out a breeze. Highly recommend this home especially for group!

We had a great stay! The place was exactly as described and comfortably accommodated our group of seven with plenty of space for everyone. It was very convenient to have a small neighborhood convenience store within walking distance for quick supplies. We especially appreciated the sound machine—since it was New Year’s, the neighborhood was a bit lively, and that thoughtful touch made a big difference. The host was very responsive and easy to communicate with throughout our stay. We would definitely recommend this place to others.

Our group of 6 stayed here from a Thursday-Monday. The house was very comfortable, spacious, and clean. We enjoyed the pool and all of the amenities in the kitchen. We also really appreciated Romaines recommendations for walkable restaurants! The beach clubs on the south part of the island are walkable (10-15mins), and we easily hailed Taxis for our visits to the north part of the island. The house is located in a residential area, which we appreciated. The only concern was the loud partying at the house across the street on Saturday & Sunday night. The sound machines helped a bit, and we acknowledge that is not the fault of the AirBNB host, but if you have young children or are sensitive to loud music and talking then you may want to bring noise cancelling headphones for the weekend nights. Otherwise, everything went smoothly!

4BR Villa in Isla Mujeres

John

Excellent, 1 year ago

Exactly as described, spacious, and a spotless and CLEAN vacation home. Would certainly recommend a golf cart rental for transportation. The home is in a noisy neighborhood, but nothing that isn’t manageable, it’s the local atmosphere (only mentioning to counter some of the previous reviews). Would stay here again!

We mostly enjoyed our stay at Casa Macabi - the pictures are fairly accurate and the neighborhood is situated in a very convenient location to good restaurants and a close walk/drive to the grocery stores and the south part of the island. This may have been a function of the fact that we were there over New Year's week but the neighborhood was unbelievably noisy - dogs were constantly barking and music was playing at club levels. We had to turn our music off because our speaker couldn't keep up and while they provided us with noise machines in the bedrooms, it really didn't cover the noise. The manager was extremely responsive and communicative but there did seem to be a lot of issues that needed to be taken care of. They were very accommodating of our schedule which we appreciated.

We went to Isla Mujeres to celebrate my 30th birthday. Casa Macabi is absolutely stunning, just like the pictures! It’s about a 15 minute golf cart ride from the center and the main beach. When we first got there, the water heater wasn’t working and the gas stove was also not working. I did let the host know, and they did come and fix those things the following day. Other than that, it was a beautiful stay , peaceful, and quiet!

At the time of this review, there are two addresses for this property. One from Airbnb, and another in the guidebook. This caused tons of confusion at check-in and resulted in our family delaying entry by 45 mins upon arrival. This was especially difficult after a 10 hour travel day with a two year old. I asked for a pack and play for our toddler at time of booking, and then reminded again one week prior to arrival. There was no pack and play upon entry. We took a risk and put our toddler in a regular bed for the night, something we had never done before. They arrived with a pack and play a few hours later after we already put our toddler to bed. For the above two items, we decided to give 4 stars. The rest of the stay was excellent. We loved the house, it has incredible charm! From the staircase to the artwork to the master bedroom/bathroom, the house really stood out as authentic. After a bumpy arrival, we had a great stay. If check-in improves, this is 5 stars!

I recently stayed at the Casa Macabi to celebrate my 30th birthday with friends and had a fantastic experience! Delia was incredibly welcoming and accommodating, making sure that we had everything we needed for a comfortable stay. The property itself was beautiful and well-maintained, with all the amenities we could have asked for. The location was perfect, close to restaurants, shops, and attractions, making it easy for us to explore the area. The check-in process was seamless, and the host provided us with all the information we needed to make the most of our stay. Overall, I would highly recommend this Airbnb to anyone looking for a cozy and convenient place to stay. The host's hospitality and attention to detail really made our trip special, and I would definitely stay here again in the future.

A Jewel in the Middle of the Island We are 4 mature couples that booked Casa Macabi for a 3 day excursion to Isla Majures. Upon our check in, we were very impressed with this residence. The living spaces had quality furnishings and appliances; good assortment of cooking utensils; etc. The outdoor patio area was a dream. With a good seating area, nice pool as well as an outdoor kitchen, this became our gathering place for conversation and refreshments. The master suite was the crowning jewel. The king bed sits under a large dome with a skylight and has two balconies overlooking the city. This residence is very well outfitted and decorated with top quality furniture and fixtures. All beds were reported to be very comfortable. The location is a quieter area than staying downtown, however there are options within walking distance for groceries or dining. For us the location was great as we wanted to be outside the party zone. We would highly recommend this unit.

Casa Macabi is a beautiful home in the rougher/more residential section of Isla Mujeres. To be clear, we did not feel unsafe, but nearby/walkable restaurants or cafes were limited. It's about 1,5hr by foot or 20m by golf cart to the northern beach where you have options to go out. For those who prefer an oasis and don't mind a drive-- it is a great space where we felt at home to watch TV, cook shared meals, and hang by the pool. The master bedroom is especially magnificent. In general all the rooms and furnishings were well considered! there were even floation devices :) We had some trouble in the neighborhood locating the spot, the street was missing numbers and taxis could not find it, keep that in mind when planning you will need to get a golfcart quickly or always call for taxis because it is a very quiet area.

Breasy

Buy. Rent. Easy. Vacation rentals across Central America.

Explore

RentFor property managersAI agents

Destinations

Costa RicaMexicoNicaraguaAll destinations
Costa Rica

© 2026 Breasy. All rights reserved.

All destinations