Sarah
Reviews
Superhost22 total reviews
91% rated 5★
22 reviews
4.86
2025–2026
22 reviews

Hector
Excellent, 1 month ago
Casa Stella is an amazing, beautiful, well designed home that truly thought of everything when it was designed. Our host David was incredible and attentive cannot speak any more highly of him. Same as house keeper Chavella. Casa Stella hosted our family vacation of 10 with 4 grandchildren at one point our 6 year old granddaughter said “this is the life” lol. We highly recommend Casa Stella for your vacation. Also pictures on Airbnb are nice but when you walk in you will truly be WOWED!

Esaid
Excellent, 1 month ago
We arrived on Sunday. The house is a real luxury, but above all, it is a pleasure to enjoy each and every area. It has amazing finishes worthy of a luxury house on the beach. Mrs. Isabel was always attentive to us. Everything was tidy and clean every day (personally, I did not expect this). The only thing is that to get to the house, you have to go up a very steep slope. I hope we can improve that. Otherwise, everything was excellent. Thank you for sharing your house with us. HIGHLY RECOMMENDED ✅✅✅ Regards. We'll be back soon 🔜 🏝️

Karla
OK, 1 month ago
Our stay at this home was truly memorable. It is one of the most beautiful vacation homes we’ve ever stayed in. The architecture, design, layout, and lush jungle setting are absolutely breathtaking. The grounds are immaculate, and the staff were exceptional. The property manager was also extremely responsive and made every effort to resolve issues quickly. That said, there are a few important thing to know before booking. The biggest concern was the power outages. Sayulita and Puerto Vallarta are known for afternoon storms and occasional power outages. Unfortunately, the home is not equipped with a backup generator or solar battery system. Without electricity, the home’s water pumps stop working, so we were left without both power and running water. We had to flush toilets using pool water, had no air conditioning in the intense humidity. The property is above a rooster farm and crowing starts at 4am thru the whole day. All in all if a generator is installed we will for sure return!
Host Response
Karla, As you noted our house and staff were exceptional and tended to your every need with expediency and care and delivered a truly memorable experience. We aspire to deliver 5 star experience for every guest. We cannot control Mother Nature and it is unfortunate that when a storm happened that took down the electricity infrastructure for an entire town that you take issue with great people and hosts that treated you with the utmost of kindness and help to give a staggering 3 star review for your entire week long trip. I’m sorry that you had to endure a short period without electricity while the whole town was out. I assure you that all was done to go above and beyond to help you and your group have a wonderful stay. We wish you the best.

Sharon
Excellent, 2 months ago
Casa Stella was everything and more! Beautiful home with an even more beautiful property. Thoughtfully designed and immaculately clean, with staff that was extremely kind and helpful. The host was quick to respond to any questions we had and provided great recommendations. We are already looking forward to coming back!

Billie
Excellent, 3 months ago
Wow! This property and Hosts exceeded my groups expectations. Sarah and Travis were super helpful and they have a local property manager that was there for whatever we needed. There were no guests before us so they let us check in early. They helped us set up airport transportation, golf cart rentals, a chef and tequila tasting. The home is gorgeous and comfortable. We will absolutely be back!

Hayley
Excellent, 4 months ago
Awesome stay for my bachelorette, Sarah was couldn’t have been more responsive and helpful throughout the process — house is beautiful and exactly as pictured, so easy to take our golf cart into town and enjoy everything sayulita has to offer. We’ve already decided we want to come back and bring our guys next time :) thanks so much for everything!

Natalie
Excellent, 4 months ago
Everything was absolutely perfect. The host and her staff were amazing, they help coordinate every detail of our stay. It was so beautiful!

Michelle
Good, 4 months ago
We had a wonderful stay at Casa Stella. The location is incredible, and being surrounded by so much nature was a highlight. Traveling with my 2 daughters, I appreciated how safe and at ease we felt throughout our visit. The home itself is beautiful, filled with thoughtful spaces to gather and connect. This was a special trip for us—Thank you to Sarah, Travis and David for being so responsive and helpful. Our stay was wonderful, but there are issues to note. The listing has many inconsistencies: the laundry room was locked for our 2 week stay, no dishwasher, iron, wardrobe mirror. Additionally, kitchen spices were years past expiration. Maintenance is extensive, with staff on-site 4 to 6 hours daily; so, not a lot of privacy, nor was it comfortable to relax. Location is remote- lookout for scorpions. We found 2 in the house. Most significantly, we were not notified until arrival that the master bath was out of order, due to a major plumbing issue. David said repair would take 2 months
Host Response
It deeply saddens us that you did not feel a 5 star experience. We provide staff on site to ensure guests have a worry free vacation where dishes & laundry & cleaning are done for you. During your stay when you requested to clean yourself, we respected that request. I apologize for things that were outside of our control. We place much attention not only into our guest experience, also into cleanliness and safety. We regularly spray for all pests, yet we cannot control Mother Nature. We advise all guests to be mindful of scorpions and they are most prevalent when damp towels are left on the ground or the house goes unkept. Also the bath tub did develop a leak which is not a major plumbing issue, it is a reality of home ownership where a repair was needed. The 2 month window is due to guest occupancy where we do not want to inconvenience guests with repairs and instead requested not to use the tub. It was our pleasure to host you & we did our best to tend to your every request.

Sergio Orduño
Excellent, 5 months ago
Very comfortable house and very good services

Erin
Excellent, 5 months ago
Had a lovely time at this home - our kids were obsessed with the pool and the endless new places around the sprawling grounds to discover and enjoy. Had a bit of trouble finding the house at first given how private and secluded the property is, but it was stunning and perfect for us in every way.

Elaina
Excellent, 5 months ago
Sarah’s house was phenomenal! It was even better than the pictures. We were here for my bachelorette with 10 girls and the large private gate made us feel so safe. Taking my first steps into the house made me speechless! There were so many beautiful elements to the space and I kept finding new spots every day. It is extremely private and we felt super safe in the area. Each bedroom is stocked with its own bathroom and closet. The palapa is a beautiful addition where we had at home massages by the wonderful ladies at Nirvana Spa in town. Highly recommend this experience here. The pool was always the perfect temperature and the view was amazing!! Also, the maid service was spectacular. They serviced every day and timed it well with when we were out of the house. Thank you Sarah!!

Michael
Excellent, 6 months ago
This home is beautiful and it was the perfect private vacation spot for our family in Sayulita. If you’re looking to enjoy the town but not be in the craziness in town, this is the most beautiful space to enjoy with family. The house has everything and more that you could need. Sarah, Travis & David are great hosts and are always available to help. 10/10, I would recommend this home to everyone.

Melissa
Excellent, 6 months ago
We have rented nearly 50 Airbnbs/VRBOs and during our stay at Sarah's home in Sayulita, we concluded over and over that this was the nicest one we've ever stayed in. The photos are gorgeous but don't even do the space justice. We stayed for five nights as two families of four and we had just enough time to enjoy every amazing space the property had to offer. Five stars for the host's friendliness and responsiveness, the property's cleanliness and amenities, and the location for enjoying what the area has to offer. Highly recommend booking Sarah's beautiful home.

Vicente
Excellent, 6 months ago
Our stay at Casa Stela in Sayulita was nothing short of exceptional. From the moment we arrived, Sarah and her entire team made us feel genuinely welcomed, cared for, and completely at home. The property itself is stunning, thoughtfully designed, beautifully maintained, and perfectly positioned to enjoy both privacy and the energy of Sayulita. Every detail felt intentional, from the layout of the spaces to the comfort of the rooms. You can tell this is a place built with heart. What truly sets Casa Stela apart is the hospitality. Sarah went above and beyond at every turn with proactive communication, seamless coordination, thoughtful recommendations, and a warmth that made the entire experience effortless. The team anticipated needs before we even had to ask. Whether it was arranging logistics, sharing local tips, or ensuring everything ran smoothly, they executed flawlessly. For a group stay especially, this is the kind of place that elevates the entire trip. It strikes the perfect

Ashley
Excellent, 7 months ago
Outstanding property. Great location and beautiful views!

Shawn
Excellent, 7 months ago
We had an amazing stay!! The pictures don’t do this place justice. The house is massive, and if you’re looking to entertain, this is the place. We stayed with 5 children from toddler to teen and all had a great time. We had a shuttle reserved for us to and from PVR. Also recommend rented a side by side or a golf cart to get around.

Paola
Excellent, 8 months ago
The house is beautiful! It's better than what you see in the photos, the pool has an ideal temperature even in winter, delicious beds! The kitchen has everything we need. I would definitely come back. Sarah and Travis are great hosts and always willing to help.

Sabrina
Excellent, 8 months ago
We absolutely loved our stay at Casa Stella -the photos truly do not do it justice—it’s even better in person! WAY better! Sarah and Travis were exceptional hosts and went above and beyond to help make our trip smooth. They had a Christmas tree set up for us and even gifts under the tree—such a warm and unexpected touch! The property is in walking distance to the main hub of Sayulita. We rented a golf cart and were so glad we did. The property is about a 20-minute walk to the beach & town, but the golf cart made it easy to run back and forth. The property is massive and beautifully set up. It has the most well-stocked kitchen I’ve ever seen in an Airbnb, plus a TV room, basketball court, outdoor bar, infinity pool, multiple outdoor dining spaces, and an outdoor kitchen. My college kids and I loved it so much that some days we didn’t even want to leave. They said it was like the house on "Love Island"! 😂 One of the most impressive properties we’ve ever stayed in! 5 STARS!

Zac
Excellent, 9 months ago
Very nice place. Looks even better in person than in the pictures. Well worth the cost, would book again. House is slightly on a hill. Would recommend renting a Polaris ranger/side by side getting into town and from house. But if you don’t mind walking very doable. Can’t wait to come Back!

Martin
Excellent, 9 months ago
Casa Stella is out of a dream, the pictures did not do it justice. The location is amazing and the views are to die for. The world class bird watching and variety of butterflies were amazing while swimming with the kids. The property itself is HUGE and has plenty of space to entertain and enjoy different sections of the home on a daily basis. Can’t wait to be back

Charles
Excellent, 9 months ago
Casa Stella was an amazing stay for my wife and I, my sisters family, and my parents, with four kids including two infants in tow. The infinity pool was an all day hangout, and the wide open space in the main building and the palapa made family bonding time very natural. It was one of those rare experiences where the reality surpassed the expectations and the pictures. The hosts were some of the most responsive we have interacted with. Having visited the area for five years now, Casa Stella will probably be a favorite of ours to stay for years to come!

Susana
Excellent, 10 months ago
Beautiful house, with multiple living areas, very nice design in general, equipped with everything you need and very accessible with schedules and willingness to help at all times