John
Reviews
60 total reviews
98% Excellent
60 reviews
4.98
2019–2026
Cleanliness 5.0
Accuracy 5.0
Communication 4.9
Location 5.0
Check-in 5.0
Value 4.9
60 reviews

Cillian
Excellent, 1 week ago
We had a wonderful 10 days in Casa Iscaja, Carrillo village and beach are quiet and very friendly local vibe, The house, pool and views are perfect for lazy days and lots of tours and activities nearby - surfing, kayak, whale watching .... Perfect family holiday
Host Response
Cillian, thank you very much for your very kind words about your stay in Casa Iscaja. So glad to hear how much you’ve enjoyed the various activities in the area.

Jonathan
Excellent, 3 weeks ago
John’s place was honestly amazing—one of the best Airbnbs we’ve stayed at. The house is beautiful, super clean, and even better than the photos. It just felt easy and relaxing the whole time. Elieth and Girrado really made the stay though. They were awesome—super friendly, helpful, and always around if we needed anything. They went above and beyond and made everything feel taken care of. Would 100% recommend staying here. We’ll definitely be back.
Host Response
Thank you so much Jonathan, for your happy review. It was a pleasure to host you and we hope to see you again!
Diana
Excellent, 5 months ago
We had a wonderfully peaceful week in pristine surroundings. The house was immaculate and very well set up to ensure each guest privacy as every room was en suite. The staff took great care of us. We had a beautiful breakfast prepared daily. They also booked our excursions for us. They ensured daily that our needs were all being taken care of. The house itself is phenomenal. Beautifully decorated, comfortable, and peaceful. We also hosted a birthday dinner, and the owners were accommodating in helping us to find a local chef, flowers, and musician. I highly recommend this beautiful country and home. I cannot express enough how well we were taken care of and how comfortable each guest felt. Pure vida! Warmest regards, Diana Walker
Host Response
You were superbly nice guests and we loved hosting you. Thank you so much for your nice and kind words. We certainly hope to welcome you back in the future. Warmest regards, Carla and John
Grahame And Katie
Excellent, 5 months ago
What an incredible stay our family of 7 had at Casa Iscaja! It was absolutely gorgeous and we are missing the views already. A cup of coffee, with that amazing view, watching the monkeys in the trees from the balcony…doesn’t get better than that. We were there with our 4 young children and felt very safe and comfortable the whole time. It was so peaceful, super clean, and Elieth made us some delicious breakfasts during our stay. We would love to stay again the next time our travels bring us to Costa Rica. Thank you!
Host Response
It’s so lovely to hear that your family had such a great time in Casa Iscaja! We hope to welcome you again!
Marty
Excellent, 6 months ago
Paradise. This may be our best AirBnB ever. CR is a beautiful country with friendly welcoming people. Casa Iscaja is a private, luxurious haven offering a peaceful escape from a hectic world. The home is exactly as pictured and is perfectly maintained and meticulously cleaned by the wonderful on-site caretakers who are around as much or as little as requested. Eli is also a great cook. The owners are friendly and helpful with fast and clear communication. We loved our time there so much, we extended our stay by a week. We highly recommend Casa Iscaja and look forward to an opportunity to come back.
Host Response
Thank you so much for your generous and gracious review! We couldn’t have nicer guests, than yourselves! We would love to welcome you back again!
Shalon
Excellent, 6 months ago
Absolutely Stunning! We hit a home run with Casa Iscaja! Such a beautiful clean home with the most spectacular views. We were lucky to see whales and monkeys everyday and some amazing sunsets It is close to town and beaches but far enough away to feel secluded It is truly heaven on earth. The hosts Carla and John were wonderful very responsive. They checked in on us and made sure we didn’t need anything The home was perfect. There was plenty of area for 6 of us and plenty of shade to get out of the afternoon sun. The pool was absolutely amazing! The house is maintained extremely well the landscaping is beautiful and kept up the house is well appointed with everything we needed Elieth and Gerardo were the icing on the top! They are so kind and worked very hard everyday to keep everything clean and tidy even throughout the terrible wind storms Breakfast was very delicious every morning! Elieth did our laundry We were so spoiled! Without hesitation we would stay here again!
Host Response
We are so happy to hear how much all of you have enjoyed your stay in Casa Iscaja! Thank you so much for your very kind and enthusiastic review! We, of course would love to host you again!
Steven
Excellent, 7 months ago
The place was incredible. Eli and Gerardo were very professional and helpful. From preparing scrumptious breakfasts to setting up our tours with excellent local guides, they made our vacation great. The home was well appointed and decorated. The view, the pool, the house, and the hospitality were all exceptional. Thank you for welcoming our family. We hope to be back sometime soon!
Host Response
Thank you so much Steven, for your very kind words. So wonderful to know how much your family have enjoyed your vacation in Casa Iscaja! We’d love to welcome you again!
Mathieu
Excellent, 7 months ago
The property was truly beautiful and the views breathtaking. Perfect for two families, we had privacy in the 4 bedrooms with private baths. Outside space was comfortable to lounge watching the sunset and plenty of shaded areas to hide from the warm sun. Elieth’s breakfasts were delicious to start the day. The grounds and property were spotless and very well maintained. Very quiet area surrounded by nature. Short drive from Carrillo beach where you can enjoy the beautiful ocean. Would go back in a heartbeat.
Host Response
thank you so much for your lovely words. always delighted when our guests have enjoyed the comforts of Casa Iscaja and the beauty of the area and we would of course love to welcome you again!
Jennie
Excellent, 8 months ago
The house was everything it looks to be . It has great outdoor space with an amazing views. It is certainly a luxurious wonderful place to stay. From opening your curtains in the morning to seeing the ocean you can spend the whole day taking all the scenery in whilst listening to ocean waves. John and Carla were always very responsive and always happy to help you out. I would highly recommend the house ..you definitely won't be disappointed.
Host Response
Thank you Jennie, for your kind words. It has been such a pleasure to host you and we love it when our guests appreciate the special location of the house and the surroundings as much as we do.
Alec
Excellent, 1 year ago
Wonderful house, exactly as described. Spectacular view, perfectly clean, great pool. Thanks again.
Host Response
Thank you so much, Alec! We hope to host you again. Best wishes, Carla&John
Rachel
Excellent, 1 year ago
John and Carla were wonderful hosts before we even arrived. My family and I were receiving information and communication was clear on how to get to the house, what was included, and recommendations for the area. The house was absolutely beautiful, very peaceful, rooms were spotless, and we were welcomed with open arms from both Gerardo and Elieth. Gerardo and Elieth could not have been more welcoming and friendly. They both made sure we had everything we needed, laundry was done, and the house was always spotless. Elieth made us a wonderful breakfast each morning and we paid extra to have her cook dinner one night for us (she made a local Costa Rican dish with both vegetarian options and beef options for a very reasonable price- $80 for 5 people). Gerardo always made sure the outside steps were clean and dry so no one slipped. Neither spoke English but we had a great time learning Spanish and had no issues communicating with either of them. I cannot recommend this home enough!!
Host Response
Thank you so much Rachel, for your very words! We loved renting our house to you and you are more than welcome to come back again!
Bracken
Excellent, 1 year ago
Absolutely fantastic stay. Great location close to beaches and activities. Enjoyed the pool during day, and enjoyed movie room in evenings as a family. Housekeepers were fantastic and very helpful at every moment we needed them but never intrusive. Would highly recommend without hesitation.
Host Response
Thank you for your lovely review! So glad that all have had a great time despite the delay you’ve had. Hope to host you again!
Heather
Excellent, 1 year ago
We had a wonderful stay at John's place. It was exactly like the pictures, it was beautiful, peaceful and surrounded by nature. We were able to easily get into town and loved the quaint restaurants and shops. It is an incredible rental with everything you need and more! One note - we are not used to having full-time staff at our rentals (we have stayed in many with staff that is accessible if needed) so that was a big adjustment. The caretakers were very helpful but at times we felt like we were walking on eggshells and were not able to really settle in with their oversight. The pro was incredible breakfasts and other meals as well as help if anything came up. The language barrier was also a struggle as they speak no English and we speak very little Spanish. Just something to think about if you have not stayed in places with live in staff.
Host Response
Dear Heather, thank you so much for your very nice review. I wish you would have told us during your stay that you felt slightly uncomfortable with too much attention by our staff. We could have easily asked them to restrict their presence during the day. We really hope to welcome you back to Casa Iscaja in the future!
Lindsey
Excellent, 1 year ago
We had an incredible stay at this beautiful house in Costa Rica! The location was perfect, nestled in a serene area that offered both privacy and easy access to local attractions. Whether we were relaxing by the pool, enjoying the lush surroundings, or heading out to explore, everything was within reach. The house itself was stunning, with spacious rooms and a modern design that blended perfectly with the natural beauty outside. It was fully equipped with everything we needed, making us feel right at home. The hosts were incredibly accommodating, going above and beyond to ensure we had everything we needed. From helpful recommendations on things to do nearby to their quick responses to any questions, they made our stay even more enjoyable. Overall, we couldn’t have asked for a better place to stay, and we’d definitely recommend it to anyone looking for a peaceful, well-located retreat in Costa Rica!
Host Response
Dear Lindsey, thank you so much for your kind and beautifully written review which reflects so well what we intended to achieve when we started this project. We hope to welcome you again to Casa Iscaja in the future!
Audrey
Excellent, 1 year ago
Elieth and Gerardo taking care of the villa on site are extraordinary of kindness. Very attentive and providing services. Unfortunately, we had a power and water outage one day from 8am to 5pm and Elieth had prepared water supplies for us in advance. Unfortunately, the access road had also suffered disturbances so we couldn't get out that day as we had planned. But Gerardo was able to inquire and help us with all our requests. Extraordinary stay and sunsets to fall…
Host Response
Thank you very much for your stay; it was a pleasure to host all of you! The electricity issue unfortunately affected the whole area and fortunately does not happen often… one of those things beyond our control…