Amy
Reviews
95 total reviews
97% Excellent
95 reviews
4.97
2020–2024
95 reviews

Joyce
Excellent, 1 year ago
Amy was great! Lupita, the island coordinator, was super attentive and helped us set everything up that we needed. Amy’s condo is tasteful and comfortable. The property pool was great!! Premises is clean and beautifully landscaped. If you’re staying on the island, definitely get a golf cart and stay at Amy’s place! Some really fantastic restaurants within walking distance. The north shore and nightlife is a fun golf cart ride to! Isla Mujeres is definitely a good time!

Chris
Excellent, 1 year ago
Amy's place was fantastic. Freshly cleaned, accurately depicted in photos and was exactly what we needed for a quiet getaway. Amy was a great host. Amy was responsive and proactive in checking in to make sure we were happy. I would stay again and I recommend her place.
Host Response
Thanks, Chris, for your feedback. I am glad to read you had a great stay despite arriving when Hurricane Helene had just exited. And delighted to hear you had Angelita the chef swing by and teach you how to cook a few local dishes (she is the best!).

Maggie
Excellent, 1 year ago
Beautiful house. Exactly as described. It’s away from the town in a peaceful, quiet area! Beautiful beach and beautiful view from the balcony. You’d need a cart to get around or just take a taxi like we did. Management was great too. We were welcomed by Luis who gave us a walkthrough of the property as well as show us where everything was.
Host Response
Thanks for being a five star guest, Maggie. Thanks also for mentioning it is entirely possible to navigate the island by taxi (or bus) -- and for remembering Luis. Happy to read you made the most of your stay!

Emily
Excellent, 1 year ago
This place was amazing! Although it’s in the south side of the island and you likely need a golf cart to ride around or a taxi the place itself has a lot of charm. Waking up to an amazing ocean view and the decorations Amy’s place is wonderful! Was very helpful with any questions and concerns as well as very responsive.
Host Response
Thanks, Emily, for being a great guest. Happy to read you loved your stay at Punta Sur -- most definitely the south end of the island. Unrelated, may you be proof to future guests that it is possible to make a late-night ferry. Cheers to you for being a bit of a risk taker! ;)

Margot
Excellent, 2 years ago
Best Place on Isla. This was our second stay. Amy is an amazing host, and thanks to her team we had an awesome stay again. We will be back :)
Host Response
Thanks, Margot, for being a 5-star guest x 2. Happy to read you had an awesome stay. You are, of course, welcome back any time!

Jess
Excellent, 2 years ago
Amy's place was awesome! Spacious place with great views! The pool was great and quiet. Beach clubs and restaurants within walking distance. Rancho Capricho and Kin Ha being two of out favorite spots. A golf cart is recommended for getting around the rest of the island. 10/10! Can't wait to return!
Host Response
Thanks, Jess, for your review. It is good to read you took full advantage of the local businesses. You definitely made the most of Punta Sur. Cheers to you! And than you again.

Yerik
Excellent, 2 years ago
I’m gonna keep it short and sweet. ABSOLUTELY BEAUTIFUL CONDO!! Perfect romantic setting for my wife and I to celebrate our 1 year anniversary!! If I could give 100 stars I would!!
Host Response
Thanks, Yerik. Happy to read Sotaveno was a great place to celebrate your anniversary!

Patrick
Excellent, 2 years ago
Amys place was outstanding! Beautiful and the view from the loft out the window to the ocean was unbeatable. Her whole team was incredibly helpful in arranging transportation, golf cart rentals, recommendations for food, everything. Amy herself helped me arrange for my surprise proposal and it went seamlessly. We will absolutely stay here again if it’s still available.
Host Response
Thanks for your 5-star review -- and for putting your trust in our suggestions for a memorable, surprise proposal. We enjoyed the challenge. Wishing you a 5-star engagement, wedding and marriage. Cheers to both of you!

Jessica
Excellent, 2 years ago
This place was wonderful!! We enjoyed the more laid back and relaxing vibe of this part of the island - but still lots of great restaurants (Ulan, Lacadona coffee bus, Rancho, etc) and right above Garrafon de Castilla for some easy snorkeling. Getting around the island was so easy via golf cart or taxi and Amy was a wonderful host, happy to answer questions that came up. Would definitely stay here again!

Shelbi
Excellent, 2 years ago
Great place to stay to be away from the little city and noise. It was peaceful and super convenient having a cute little beach bar/access right below the house and was not busy. The house is comfortable and the property hosts on isla were so helpful with recommendations. The place felt like a home away from home.
Host Response
Thanks, Shelbi, for being a 5-star guest -- and for making Sotavento your home away from home. Happy to read your stay was comfortable and relaxing. Cheers!

Frank
Excellent, 2 years ago
This place is beautiful clean and safe I highly recommend this Gem, I can’t wait to go back to this lovely place! Thank you Amy
Host Response
Thanks Francisco, for being a gem of a guest! The desire to return is the highest of compliments. Cheers!!

Judy
Excellent, 2 years ago
Amy’s place was amazing! The property was beautiful looks better in person. From the moment I booked every question I had Amy answered swiftly and even connected me with a driver to pick me up from the airport to the ferry. Last minute I ended up going on this trip solo but it turned out amazing. I would suggest getting a golf cart things are walkable but the humidity and flexibility that comes with having a golf cart is unmatched. Luckily there are taxis pretty much every minute driving by so I just used that as my main source of transportation. Everything is fairly within distance restaurants, beaches & night life. Will definitely be visiting again !
Host Response
Thanks, Judy for being five star guest. Happy to read all went well starting with your airport pick-up!

Shamiya
Excellent, 2 years ago
This is our 2nd stay at this condo within the past year and it is still 5 stars. 1. The owner Amy is extremely responsive. 2. The Property Manager Lupita is extremely responsive and accommodating with any surprises you may have. 3. The location is on the South end of the island, which is peaceful and beautiful. 4. The home is clean, spacious, safe and secure. 5. Rancho (nearby can walk) has the BEST tacos on the island so check it out. 6. Book Now! This is definitely our home away from home and we look forward to visiting again.
Host Response
Thanks, Shamiya, for making Sotavento your home away from home the second time around! And oh yes, those tacos are really something. : )

Danielle
Excellent, 2 years ago
loved staying here. Lupita was so helpful in our stay. sadly they were working on the pool during our stay. but the pool looked beautiful for future stays! they let us know ahead of time and even gave us the option to find a new place if we wanted! we decided to stay! we could have stayed there forever!
Host Response
Thanks, Danielle, for your positive review and feedback -- and for taking a chance and staying during the pool overhaul. Wanting to never leave is, of course, a wonderful compliment Cheers!

Sharon
Excellent, 2 years ago
Perfect for the two of us. Great location, communication and comfort! We found so many great food places and beach clubs. Playa Norte was beautiful and the south end had many little restaurants. Loved the deck for morning coffee and evening cocktails. Definitely rent a golf cart so you can see everything this little island has to offer. Amy was great at answering all our questions. Loved it!!!
Host Response
Thanks, Sharon, for your feedback And special thanks for putting your trusting Alan for your trip to Isla Contoy and the fishing trip. Happy to read you loved your stay.